alternatives to wind turbines

I discovered on the site “Popular Science” the following alternatives to wind turbines and wanted to share them since this topic comes up a lot in class:


“One common complaint about wind turbines is that they blemish the scenic countrysides and coastlines where they perch. Now an architect in London has an attractive solution. The “wind dam,” a giant swath of fabric connected to a turbine, looks more like a Christo art installation than a power generator.

The biggest inefficiency of current wind technology, says Laurie Chetwood, founder of the architectural firm Chetwood Associates, is that more wind passes around turbines than through their rotors. So he hit upon the idea of boosting productivity by capturing high-speed winds with a massive spinnaker sail—like those that yachts deploy to pick up extreme speed—anchored to cliffs on either side of a valley and funneling those winds through a central turbine. Based on a computer model of the dam, he expects it to produce up to 120 megawatts per year, enough to power about 35 homes.

But the design has drawn some criticism. Stephen Connors, a wind-energy expert at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Energy Initiative doesn’t think the dam could stand up to winds gusting in multiple directions. And, because wind hitting the sail would create turbulence, the dam could struggle to concentrate wind on the turbine. Even if it did, Connors says, the wind would lose significant speed on its way to the rotors.

Chetwood is working on these problems—the sail will probably be conical to limit turbulence, and the architects will build in areas with winds that blow predominantly in one direction to reduce stress on the dam. He has teamed with a Finnish engineering firm and is seeking permission to build a privately financed $5-million, 17,000-square-foot Kevlar wind dam in a valley close to Lake Ladoga, near the Baltic Sea, as soon as 2009. After that, he may modify the design to fit on a bridge or skyscraper, where at the very least it would give passersby something colorful to look at.

How it Would Work

Two aluminum legs support the 17,000-square-foot Kevlar sail, which is anchored to cliffs in a valley near Lake Ladoga. The conical shape of the sail directs air to three in-line turbines, which are enclosed in a tube. The wind spins each turbine’s blades and turns an axle that runs into its gearbox. The gearbox steps up the rotational speed of a shaft that spins magnets around a wire inside the generator to transform the movement into electricity through electromagnetic induction.”

Here are two other models developing on this concept:

A student at Arizona State University has proposed overpass-mounted turbines that, based on windspeeds of at least 10 mph kicked up by cars, could each produce enough electricity to power one small home.

The floating Superturbine can be moored farther offshore than traditional turbines. Multiple high-speed rotors increase energy output, and a carbon-fiber frame and flexing mechanisms help it survive storms.


One response to “alternatives to wind turbines

  1. Jacques Mattheij

    The turbines over the highway concept will not work because it will increase the energy required to drive the vehicles on the highway. Effectively any energy generated by it will have to come out of an increased fuel consumption.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s